Tonight, the third season finale of Battlestar Galactica airs on the Sci-Fi channel. Among other things (like the possible reveal of the five final Cylons), the fate of Gaius Baltar is almost sure to be decided. He’s on trial on charges of collaborating with the Cylons, and since enough evidence doesn’t exist to charge him with sabotauging Colonial defenses before the twelve colonies were nuked into non-existance, he’s being charged for his actions on New Caprica.
But is he guilty? Is he guilty of handing humanity over to the Cylons?
I’m going to go out on a limb here and say “no.”
Don’t get pissy with me! Sure, Baltar’s a slimy, duplicitious wanker, sure, no one’s going to cry if someone — like a bunch of Marines — lays a beat down on him.
Consider, though:
1. Why did Baltar provide the Cylons with access to the Defense Mainframe prior to the attack? It wasn’t because he wanted to see humanity wiped out, it was because - oh yeah - he was sleeping with that hot tall blonde chick who he thought was working for a defense contractor. If he’d ever done her doggy-style and noticed her glowing red spine — and then not altered Colonial security, yeah, well, then you might have a case.
2. As for denying involvement in the Cylon attack afterward — well, shit, wouldn’t you? Would you admit you helped kill billions of people because you wanted some tail? I’m guessing … no.
3. As for New Caprica … I guess you can debate the wisdom of settling down like Baltar ordered, but you could even consider that decision a referendrum from the vote that elected him president.
4. And once the Cylons showed up — sure, Baltar should’ve shown some fucking backbone, should’ve stood up to the Cylons, even if it got him thrown into jail or executed. But is cowardice a crime worth executing? For me, the question becomes, ‘would life on New Caprica have been any better or worse if the Cylons hadn’t had a figurehead president to rule through?’ I don’t think it would’ve been.
So, that’s my verdict on Baltar.
(Oh - although his role in the death of the Marine on Pegasus in “Resurrection Ship Pt. II” can possibly be defended by the inhuman treatment shown to that prisoner by that ship’s crew).
