December 16, 2009

I Have Nothing Against Abstinence Education

Filed under: Uncategorized — MalSnay @ 7:49 am

Honestly, I don’t get why anyone could possibly have anything against encouraging young folk to avoid having sex. It’s sort of like encouraging a driver never to crash his car.

But, y’know what? I bet you’d never give your car keys to a teenage who has never had so much as a driver’s ed course. I bet you’d want to make sure that the person you were entrusting with your car knows how to operate a clutch, and to stop at a red light. I bet you’d want to make sure he wouldn’t do rolling stops, and would keep his eyes open for pedestrians, and would yield at crosswalks, and use his turn signal. I bet you’d want all this not just to make sure you get your car back in one piece, but because you wouldn’t want him to have to be scraped off its innards after he plays chicken with a bus and loses.

I bet you’d tell him to buckle up.

And that’s why I have something against abstinence only education: you’re giving a young person the key to your car and you’re telling him “Don’t get in a car wreck!”

What does this pedal do? How does the wheel works? What about that button, this stalk? Naw, don’t worry about it, you don’t need to know: just don’t get in a car wreck, and everything’ll be fine.

Once again, there’s an article out about young peoples’ misunderstandings of how to use contraception:

Also, 29 percent of women and 42 percent of men said it is at least slightly likely they will have unprotected sex in the next three months — and it’s quite likely or extremely likely for 17 percent of women and 19 percent of men.

The discrepancy between both wanting to plan pregnancy and having unprotected sex may have something to do with a focus in recent years on abstinence-only education, said Laura Lindberg, senior research associate at the nonprofit Guttmacher Institute.

“Abstinence-only curriculums have gone explicitly out of their way to teach misconceptions about contraception,” she said. “This generation of 20-somethings have missed many opportunities to get medically accurate and correct information.”

Many of the people surveyed said they did not know much about contraception to begin with — 63 percent said they knew little or nothing about birth control pills, and 30 percent said they had scant knowledge about condoms.

The numbers may reflect that while most people have heard of the pill and condoms, they have never been taught how to use the pill or where to get it, or how to put on a condom, said Dr. Yolanda Wimberly, assistant professor of clinical pediatrics at the Morehouse School of Medicine and an adolescent medicine specialist with Grady Health Systems in Atlanta, Georgia.

Myths about pregnancy and sexual activity continue to permeate circles of young people. For instance, 28 percent of men incorrectly believe they will get extra protection from wearing two condoms at once, a practice that actually leads to condom breakage. At the same time, 18 percent of men wrongly believe that having sex standing up reduces the chance that they will get a female partner pregnant.

These are the kinds of myths often heard in Wimberly’s office. Wimberly, who sees young people from age 12 to 30 about sexual health issues, commonly hears rumors like these that have spread among friends. Anecdotal evidence that a behavior is safe is sometimes more convincing for young adults than the recommendations of health professionals.

Hey, don’t worry, you’ll be fine driving, even if you’re only ever learned how to drive by watching your parents, and movies. Hey, little Jimmy from down the block? That’s how he learned: how many accidents has he had? None. See? You’ll be totally fine. Just drive like Jimmy, and don’t get in a car wreck.

Guess what: back in college, I knew a girl who bragged (I mean, not openly, but to a circle of mutual friends) that she’d never ever used protection during sex, and she’d never gotten pregnant, and never gotten an STD, and this is not a woman I would describe as chaste. Based on that: are you going to go without a condom the next time you’re getting horizontal?

The biggest (and sadly, the best) argument I’ve ever heard in favor of abstinence only education is something along the lines of, “If you teach people how to have safe sex, then they’ll have sex.” But the problem is that the argument assumes that if people don’t know how to have safe sex, they won’t have sex at all, and I think that’s pretty shortsighted.

And then there’s this gem of a quote:

“I don’t think we’ll be able to overcome this problem unless we restore the social norm of not having sex and not getting pregnant before marriage,” said Peter Sprigg, senior fellow for policy studies at the Family Research Council.

Y’know, I don’t actually believe that the social norm was ever not having sex until marriage. I think that may have been the ideal (probably still is), and the pretended norm, but c’mon: people are randy. It’s not like, before Woodstock, everyone was magically a virgin until marriage, and then afterwords, everyone started fucking like bunny rabbits for ever and ever and ever.

9 Comments »

  1. Excellent work. Very well put. Couldn’t agree more.

    Comment by Jules — December 16, 2009 @ 9:37 am

  2. Actually, I’m pretty sure that WAS the social norm, although I would maybe put the line of demarcation a little earlier in the 60′s. I know, it seems hard for someone of your age to believe.

    People were better able (or willing?) to control themselves back then.

    Comment by Jim McKee — December 16, 2009 @ 12:45 pm

  3. i’m glad you explained yourself, because i read the title and was all “UM, I HAVE SOMETHING AGAINST IT!! …oh.”

    also, per Jim’s comment – I’m not so sure. i think it’s like how celebrities “these days” are more promiscuous. not true: history has shown that men in power have ALWAYS had affairs (JFK, anyone??) but that it was just easier to cover up, less media prying, people respected power and wouldn’t tattle, etc. i bet before the 60s, people just didn’t TALK about premarital sex as much. and/or sent a lot of women to “live with relatives” or “go to boarding school” for 9 months at a time until they could come back and keep on being virginal.

    Comment by Alice — December 16, 2009 @ 1:51 pm

  4. Al Franken for one of his books solicited personal tales of abstinence from conservative figures. The silence was deafening. They can’t even pretend to practice what they preach.

    Comment by yellojkt — December 16, 2009 @ 2:54 pm

  5. People did have sex before marriage, and they did get pregnant. The difference then was that it was considered shameful and stupid. Smart people and “nice” people waited for true love. And contraception.

    Comment by jain — December 16, 2009 @ 6:42 pm

  6. Abstinence education pisses me off, first church and state are separate. Second fact and opinion are separate. You want kids to be taught the facts, not just opinions. Abstinence is an opinion, it would be like a teacher teaching about how Clinton or Bush were horrible presidents. Meanwhile, they don’t tell them the facts on what each one did and what each one failed to do. Telling kids don’t have sex, sex can give you diseases. Well, without a proper education kids won’t know oral and anal sex can also give transmit diseases as well as vaginal, since most kids do not consider that sex. It is sad that the education system is doing this to kids.

    Comment by Sean — December 17, 2009 @ 12:17 am

  7. http://www.bestfriendsfoundation.org/

    Has gotten HUGE results.

    Comment by Jim McKee — December 17, 2009 @ 12:54 pm

  8. Jim — I’m sorry, but looking over their website, I don’t see how you can say that. I think it’s all well and fine to encourage teens to resist peer pressure and to wait to have sex, until marriage, or until they’re an adult. But I think it’s absolutely foolish not to educate teens on how to have sex safely. If you read the article linked to above, lots of teens are being encourage to abstain, but they’re having sex anyway, and they don’t know how to protect themselves when they do. Abstinence-only sex education is a DANGER.

    Comment by MalSnay — December 17, 2009 @ 1:15 pm

  9. Maybe the web site doesn’t give enough info. I’ve listened to Dr. Bill Bennett speak about the program (his wife, Elayne, is the person who runs the organization), and it is incredibly positive.

    I respectfully disagree with your last statement; however, this is your web site, and so I will defer to you.

    Comment by Jim McKee — December 18, 2009 @ 10:25 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. | TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

XHTML ( You can use these tags): <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> .